Wednesday, February 17, 2010

Some other resources for working with recorded lectures

After posting yesterday’s article, I came across and article in Campus Technology which caught my eye. Campus Technology is an advertising drive trade magazine targeted to higher education IT decision makers. The article in the February 2010 issue, “Winning Them Over”, describes approaches to encourage usage of lecture capture tools by faculty who perhaps aren’t the most interested in investing time in learning how to capture lectures.

What sparked my interest was two-fold. First, there are links to studies describing the impact of lecture capture on teaching and learning. This includes what appears to be a vendor-sponsored impact study of the use of their tool at UMASS Lowell. The finding that stood out was a 10% shift from D’s and F’s to C’s or better. There are other anecdotal results in other applications. While this is certainly not definitive, it does point to a need for more formal study. Another article comes from UW-Madison investigating “student attitudes toward the value of addling lecture capture to existing courses.” Students expressed a preference for having access to lecture materials asynchronously and cited a range of uses, including making up for missed classes and reviewing materials prior to class. Perhaps most notable was that students were willing (60%) to pay for lecture capture.

The second thing worth noting us a list of tools for enhancing lecture capture. Some were familiar repositories of University teaching materials (MIT OpenCourseWare, MERLOT, Wikimedia Commons, YouTube EDU, iTunes U). Others were resources to help locate free multimedia resources (either public domain or royalty-free) including EveryStockPhoto, Incompetech for music, and Creative Commons Search.

The availability of these resources to enhance lectures led me to reflect on the quality of the lectures I’ve previously recorded. You might note I have not posted links to my class recordings. That’s because when recording an hour lecture it either restricts use of active learning techniques (everything needs to take place on screen) or requires editing (breaks and alternate data feeds like video) to incorporate them into the recording. With practice, editing with a professional tool like Adobe Premiere or even Windows Movie Maker is not too bad. But the quality can be turned up another notch.

Adobe has taken a package from their Macromedia purchase (which I believe Macromedia bought from another company) and re-released it as Adobe Presenter. What the software does is take video, audio, and text and merge them into a production quality presentation with minimal skills. Picture in picture effects, green-screen effects, all sorts of things which previously required difficult to learn professional software are now readily available. Adobe Presenter, now being sold as Version 7, looks like a tool to take ordinary screen captures to another level, easily incorporating live video recordings with audio, screen-capture, and text. Presenter does not appear to be available with academic pricing yet, but I would expect that to change when the full Adobe Creative Suite 5 is released. My guess is that will occur during Q3 of 2010, but Adobe is notoriously quiet about impending releases. They don’t seem to like to see their current cash flow drive up as people wait for the next big thing to be released.

Tuesday, February 16, 2010

Screen capture at any (or no) price

Sometimes even a fair price isn’t good enough when you are as… frugal, as I am. Techsmith, makers of the excellent Camtasia software for screen video capture and editing, have long offered the education community their products at a significant discount. I am a current licensee of their screen capture software, Snag-it, and frequently use it for lecture preparation (I like it better than Windows built-in application).

The purpose of Camtasia is simple—create a recording of everything you see on screen and combine It with sound. You can then edit and annotate the video, readily publishing it to a variety of archival and distribution friendly formats. They have a server grade product (Camtasia Relay)which allows centralized management and automated posting to a CMS (course management system, like Blackboard). It is well supported and frequently upgraded, and it is a self-contained solution. And did I mention it is easy to use?

So why would an instructor need a product like Camtasia? The obvious reason is to develop asynchronous class videos—recorded lectures that students can review at their discretion. In the event of campus epidemic, you might find it beneficial to record all of your classes so that students can catch up while they heal up. My most recent favorite use is to combine with a tablet PC or other pen-based input device (like a Wacom digitizing tablet). You can record narrated problem solutions not just for your current course section, but but by recording different problems each time you teach the course you can develop a library of instructional problem solutions that can be used to satisfy those students who learn by example. It will never substitute for an interactive recitation, but it may be a viable solution for those of us with limited time to spend in class and students with insatiable demands for examples.

Perhaps you now think that perhaps this Camtasia product is for you. Well, you can take advantage of their limited time free trial to find out for sure. But I’m willing to bet that most people who buy the software only use the core functionality of the software and will ultimately only need what an open-source software package called CamStudio offers. Fair warning—more technical skills are required.logo-new[1]

CamStudio was developed under the GNU public license to provide a free alternative to Camtasia. It is currently in what is being called a beta stage for version 2.6. Those working on the project seem to be updating periodically. I’m running a build from December 2009. It functions on both Win32 and x64 versions of Windows 7 and earlier. All of the functionality I’m interested in works in both 2.0 and 2.6b.

There is one issue with a software package related to CamStudio. There is a Codec (coding and decoding algorithm) for lossless video at low bitrate available to work with CamStudio (available on the project website) that does not appear to function correctly for x64 systems. If you are running Win32, it would be worth installing this codec to improve performance of the recorder.

Even without the codec, CamStudio works acceptably for me. I have only used the default Microsoft Video format that does little if any compression. This means that a 75 minute lecture will fill 2GB of disk space when capturing at the default 30 frames a second. You can drop that by adjusting the frame rate (15 or even 10 fps is acceptable for screen captures not involving moving video). Others prefer using the DIVx codec.

In any case, I choose to take that ridiculously large file, trim it, balance the audio, and make any other edits I want before rendering the file into a Flash video file and posting it to the web. I use Adobe Premier CS3 to edit, but a far less expensive package like the free Microsoft Movie Maker would work. In the case of this software, you should plan to output to a WMV. With either a Windows Media Video file or a FLV (Flash video), you can use an open source web client player like JWPlayer to build a web page to play the video (see this for an example). Or you can use a hosting service like YouTube. CamStudio has a built-in capacity for rendering to a SWF movie file, which will play in a web browser when the user has the free Adobe Shockwave player installed.

So now you have a set of free tools and a reason to use them. Now what’s going to stop you from providing the students more examples than they even have time to watch?