Clickers are a great way to conduct formative assessment. The biggest problem is probably equipment cost.
A review of recent innovations in classroom activity support the notion that clickers are an effective way of interacting with a classroom full of students. The literature (Chen, J. Eng. Edu., April 2010, online access restricted) also supports the use of clickers. As with anything good, there is a downside.
Clickers cost money. Someone has to pay for each student to have their own remote, and then you have to deal with broken/lost/stolen remotes. So how to cut costs but still give students the hardware they need?
Well, Microsoft may have an answer using their recently released application “Mouse Mischief”. Related to another potential cost-saver, Multipoint Server, this technology allows for multiple mouse inputs to a single computer. When paired with the PowerPoint 2010 or 2007 add-in, it enables up to a theoretical 525 mouse-wielding students to give answers to multiple choice questions or to draw on a single screen.
To use this tool, you of course need to download and install the free software on a computer connected to the common screen. Then things get interesting. You need to connect a mouse for each student through the USB port of the computer. Here’s where some planning is required.
USB (Universal Serial Bus) is a magnificent technology, but it is subject to some limits. First of all, a single host controller can handle up to 127 devices, including hubs. Some manufacturers only include one host controller in a system, and then use hubs to give you multiple external ports. So unless you determine otherwise (check Device Manager in Windows to find out if you know what to look for), assume you can only handle about 120 devices. For planning purposes, I’m going to look at an ideal class of 24 (yes, there is a catch to do this for $150), but this can be replicated for a large lecture hall using a desktop machine with multiple host controllers.
Next, you need to connect that host machine to all the mice that students will have at their desks. So now you have to consider other limits. Limits like the maximum length of a cable capped at 5m (16.4 ft) for the currently common USB 2.0 devices. This limits is shorter for older versions and if you take my advice and raid your IT department’s junk pile, you need to be aware of this. Note that this is just a cable length, and by use of the hubs you’ll need anyway, you can still populate a classroom with these devices. Note that greater cable lengths can be achieved using USB extenders and CAT5 cable, but the cost goes beyond the scope of this plan.
And speaking of hubs, these are just devices that allow you to connect multiple devices to a single USB port. So if you run a line from your computer to a hub, the hub (containing multiple ports, typically 4 to 7), you can now connect multiple mice to that port. Of course, you’ll need to reserve at least one of those ports to run a cable to the next hub.
But of course, there is another catch. Each of these hubs will need to be powered, so you will need to be able to plug in a AC adapter wherever you locate your hubs. If power is not available, don’t forget to add extension cords to your budget.
The last element is the mouse itself. I highly recommend optical mice only, or you will have increased maintenance requirements. Here’s where you can start saving some money. What IT department doesn’t have an excess of used mice? Scavenge used USB mice from wherever you can get them! Mix and match, use notebook mice, promotional mice, novelty mice—whatever you can find. You can of course buy them, and the budget proposed here does allow that. And to store them, consider a simple mouse holder for $2 that can be affixed to a convenient location near the student desk.
So how did I come up with my price? For my scenario, you need 24 mice ($4.75 each), four 7-port powered hubs ($7.99), and 4 long USB cables ($1.63). This comes to just over $150, or probably about 10% of the cost of an inexpensive clicker system. You’ll probably need some additional cables and such, and some of these retailers expect you to pay for shipping. But if you can scrounge around for extras of these items, I am convinced it can be implemented at this scale at most institutions for $100 or less.
My install is intended to go live in the spring (I don’t teach clicker friendly courses in the fall). If you give this a try, let me know!