Thursday, August 12, 2010

PowerPoint Poisoning Revisited

Those of us entering the workforce over the past couple of decades can barely remember a time when technical presentations were given with photographic slides, or perhaps notes on acetate sheets. Some may stretch their powers of recall to generate visions of teachers using only a chalkboard as a visual aid. Regardless of the images of lectures past, few will deny that PowerPoint has become a fixture of the modern classroom.

Some will argue that is not a good thing.

In my view, PowerPoint is a tool, and tools are only useful (or not). PowerPoint is easily abused. It can be a tool for outlining a lecture (or scripting it), and can save the instructor time. But investing a little more time in revising the slides (and moving extraneous information to the notes section) can make PowerPoint a tool that both saves time and improves student learning.

The main benefit PowerPoint brings to the classroom is a convenient way of sharing images (photographs, diagrams, graphs) and annotating them on the fly. PowerPoint has some tools for this, but others are out there which better leverage the power of the tablet. The University of Washington’s Classroom Presenter is one that allows easier annotation and sharing, but it is somewhat of a kludge in that it works outside of PowerPoint with some conversion required. UCSD has extended this with product with Ubiqutous Presenter which lets you put the presentation instantly on the web. Let me know of other similar software and add-ins that you’ve used successfully.

Some have prematurely declared the death of bullets, and with some reasonable arguments. A response describing some recommendations for effective presentations followed shortly after in response to the first blog.  PowerPoint is acknowledged in these articles as being a key tool for meetings, but the point is that text on a slide does not make an effective communication tool. Even in a serious engineering lecture, effort must be made to make the slides visually appealing (to retain attention) but not distract the class members.

Since some text is unavoidable, consider how you might use it more effectively in the classroom. I provide students with a printout of the slides, but with elements from the presentation removed. The intent is that they have to pay enough attention to fill in the relevant blanks. Make sure to leave space for the examples you’ll work out either on-screen or (perhaps preferably) on the whiteboard. A colleague at NC State, Lisa Bullard, uses this technique (notes with “gaps”) with handouts prepared for each module and filled in using a tablet during the lecture. Don’t reveal too much in a slide—make sure the students have a chance to think about what follows logically. And if they ask the right questions, you’ll impress them by having the answer slide already prepared!

And do not forget to use your instant feedback mechanisms (clickers and the lot, see the previous entry), especially using concept questions to both gain formative assessment data and to use as teaching tools! PowerPoint is evolving, and an instructor’s use of the tool should evolve with it.

No comments:

Post a Comment